Westborough Town Hall. Town officials placed Police Chief Todd Minardi on administrative leave on Oct. 24 and hired an outside investigator. Photo: Daderot via Wikimedia Commons (CC0)
Westborough, Mass., Police Chief Todd Minardi was sitting behind the wheel of his department-issued police SUV with an open bottle of Tito’s vodka in his hand when a Shrewsbury officer opened the driver’s door around noon on Oct. 23, according to body camera footage obtained by NBC10 Boston. He told the officers he was on vacation. Payroll records NBC10 Boston obtained show he was on the clock, and Westborough Assistant Town Manager Kimberly Foster confirmed that reading of the records to the station.
The distance between what the chief told Shrewsbury officers and what Westborough’s payroll system recorded is now part of what an outside investigator hired by the town has to sort out. So is a town vehicle that, by Shrewsbury police’s account, sat in a liquor store parking lot for more than a day.
More Than 24 Hours in a Shrewsbury Liquor Store Lot
Shrewsbury police said surveillance video showed Minardi pulling into the store’s lot on the morning of Oct. 22, NBC10 Boston reported. The SUV, an Explorer according to dispatch recordings described by The Boston Globe, did not move again until officers arrived the next day for a wellbeing check. A business owner had called 911 after noticing it parked in the same spot since the morning before. “I worried that he was dead,” the business owner told officers.
Minardi, dressed in civilian clothes, told officers he had been in the vehicle for “hours.” The video shows the encounter turning tense when he said he was fine and didn’t fully follow directions. “Chief, keep them on the steering wheel,” an officer told him. “We’re treating you with respect, keep them on the steering wheel.” The officer radioed for a supervisor and reported that the chief had his department firearm; after a lieutenant arrived, police determined he was unarmed. The incident report notes an empty Tito’s bottle in the vehicle, and a first responder said Minardi’s wife called during treatment and said he had been missing for two days.

Minardi apologized repeatedly. “I’m sorry to put you in this position,” he told officers. He eventually agreed to go to the hospital by ambulance, WCVB reported.
Shrewsbury police cited him for having an open container of alcohol. They did not charge him with operating under the influence, and the police report gives the reason, according to WHDH: the vehicle was not on when officers arrived. Westborough placed Minardi on administrative leave on Oct. 24 and said it would retain an outside investigator. Payroll records show the leave was paid for the two weeks that followed, NBC10 Boston reported. Deputy Chief Steve Tompkins is serving as acting chief. Foster told the station the matter “remains under investigation.” Minardi did not return NBC10 Boston’s call seeking comment.
Minardi rose from reserve officer to deputy chief in 2018 and chief in 2023. When the Select Board approved his contract in November 2023, the Community Advocate reported it ran through June 30, 2026, with an option for a fourth year. In September, the Massachusetts Chiefs of Police Association gave him its 2026 Community Policing Award, Boston.com reported.
An Open-Container Ticket Instead of an OUI Charge
The citation falls under Massachusetts General Laws chapter 90, section 24I. It bars an open container of alcohol in the passenger area of a vehicle on a public way or anywhere the public has access as invitees or licensees, language that reaches a store’s customer parking lot. The passenger area includes anything the driver can reach from the seat. The fine runs from $100 to $500. The statute exempts passengers in vehicles that carry people for hire and the living quarters of a motor home, but it singles out drivers: the driver of any vehicle may not possess an open container.
The heavier charge turned on whether Minardi was “operating” the SUV. The OUI statute, chapter 90, section 24, applies to anyone who operates a motor vehicle under the influence on a public way or in a place the public can access. Massachusetts courts still define operating with language from a 1928 case, Commonwealth v. Uski: “the setting in motion of the operative machinery of the vehicle.” The engine doesn’t have to be running. In June 2025, in Commonwealth v. Wurtzberger, the Supreme Judicial Court upheld the OUI conviction of an impaired man in the driver’s seat of a parked van with the engine off, because the key was turned far enough to engage the battery and the radio was on. The Appeals Court reached the same result in 2011 in Commonwealth v. McGillivary, where the defendant was found asleep with the key turned to “on” and the engine off.
The case law has limits. Sleeping in a driver’s seat, even with the engine running, does not automatically amount to operation; in Commonwealth v. Plowman in 1990, the Appeals Court ordered a new trial because the judge’s instructions left jurors believing it did. And the turned key mattered in Wurtzberger because it meant the man was still operating the van while impaired, so prosecutors didn’t have to prove his condition when he last moved it. According to the police report as WHDH described it, Minardi’s SUV wasn’t on. That leaves the drive into the lot on the morning of Oct. 22, more than a day before officers arrived, as the only clear operation in the timeline, and nothing made public so far describes his condition at that point.
A parked car isn’t a legal safe zone in Massachusetts. An open container within the driver’s reach is a fine wherever the car sits, and a key turned to power the dash has been enough to support a criminal OUI conviction.
The Vacation Claim and the Payroll Record
Minardi’s explanation to Shrewsbury officers doesn’t match Westborough’s own payroll, which shows him on the clock at the time, according to NBC10 Boston and Foster. Neither the station nor the town has said how his time was coded, whether the entries were later corrected, or what the town’s rules say about personal use of a department vehicle. Those answers decide what kind of problem the investigator is looking at. If he was off, the record should have charged his vacation time, and a vacation day that isn’t charged stays in the bank, where, depending on the terms of his contract, it can be used later or paid out. If he was working, the town was paying its top police officer while its SUV sat in a neighboring town’s liquor store lot for more than a day and, according to the first responder, his family didn’t know where he was.
How Long Paid Leave Can Last
Westborough hasn’t named its investigator or set a timeline. The Boxborough case shows how long that process can take in Massachusetts. The Select Board there put Police Chief Warren Ryder on paid administrative leave in January 2022 over payroll discrepancies in his department, allegations Ryder disputed. According to a 2023 statement from the Select Board chair, the board voted in July 2022 to hire a third-party investigator, who started on Aug. 19, 2022, and finished his report in mid-February 2023. The town issued a termination hearing notice on Feb. 24, 2023, reached a settlement agreement on April 5, and Ryder resigned effective April 7. That is about 15 months between paid leave and resignation, during which, NBC10 Boston reported, taxpayers were also funding a second police chief position.
What the Town Must Report to the State
Westborough’s decision will also go to the state. Under the 2020 police reform law, chapter 6E, section 8 requires the head of a police agency to forward misconduct complaints to the Peace Officer Standards and Training Commission’s division of police standards within 2 business days. When an internal investigation ends, the agency head must immediately send a report on its outcome, and if the recommended discipline includes retraining, suspension or termination, the report must also recommend commission action, up to revocation of the officer’s certification. Resigning doesn’t stop the reporting: if an officer leaves before an investigation ends or discipline is imposed, the agency must send the commission his full employment history and an account of the events surrounding the resignation.
Certification is what allows a person to work as a police officer in Massachusetts. The open-container fine tops out at $500. Revocation would end a law enforcement career that started in Westborough more than 30 years ago.
What Comes Next for Minardi and Westborough
Minardi remains on leave while the outside investigation runs, with Tompkins in charge of the department. The payroll entries are the thread to pull. Westborough has to square them with an SUV that sat in a liquor store lot for more than a day, and whatever it decides goes to the POST Commission.
When a police chief is found with an open bottle in a town-owned SUV, should the outcome stop at the same open-container fine any driver would face, or should the department vehicle and the town paycheck hold him to a stricter standard?
