An hour before a Tennessee trooper pulled her onto the shoulder of Armory Drive in Nashville, Stefanie Fair was at an ice cream shop in Brentwood. The former Wild Orchid singer was stopped just before 6 p.m. on June 23, 2024, for failing to move over. By the end of the stop, Tennessee Highway Patrol Trooper Keith Velez had arrested her for DUI. Her blood came back about two months later. No alcohol. No drugs.
The state has now agreed to pay her $70,000. The state Board of Claims approved the settlement, and a spokesman for the attorney general’s office said a payout should come within the next few weeks. Fair is the second sober driver to sue the Highway Patrol and win a settlement, and others are lined up behind her. Tennessee’s process for clearing a sober driver ends with dismissal of the charge and expungement of the record. Anything beyond that, the driver has to win in a lawsuit, and the state has started paying those lawsuits instead of fighting them. wsmv
What the bodycam video and the blood test showed
The stop started over a move-over violation. In bodycam footage obtained by WSMV4 Investigates, Velez tells a fellow trooper that Fair nearly hit him while he was finishing another traffic stop. Fair apologizes for not moving over, then seems confused when the trooper raises alcohol. “There’s a very distinct odor of alcohol that comes from either the person or inside the vehicle,” Velez says. Fair answers, “But on my life, I don’t drink alcohol.”
Related Articles
- A Homeowner Reported It While It Was Happening, and Deputies Found 3 Men Loading a Trailer From a Mulkeytown, Illinois, Garage
- A Utah Trooper Blocked a Subaru Police Say Went Around Cones at About 45 MPH, and Both Troopers Ended Up in the Hospital
According to WSMV, Velez wrote that Fair showed clues of intoxication, and she underwent a field sobriety test before he arrested her and charged her with DUI. Her attorney, Ben Raybin, later got video showing that she had been at an ice cream shop in Brentwood an hour before the stop, not a bar. The blood test cleared her, and the charge was dismissed. wsmv
Fair described the arrest to WSMV this way: “I was more scared being with that cop alone than I actually was inside the jail.”
None of the coverage so far includes a Highway Patrol comment on the settlement. When WSMV first reported Fair’s case in December 2024, a THP spokesman said the agency continues to review WSMV’s findings. wsmv
Why a sober driver can be arrested and booked in Tennessee before any test result
The arrest was legal in form even though the charge didn’t hold up. Tennessee, like every state, lets an officer make a DUI arrest based on what the officer observes: the odor, driving behavior, and performance on roadside tests. No lab result is needed. The blood test that can confirm or clear the driver comes afterward. In Fair’s case it took about two months, and the arrest, booking, and mugshot had all happened by then.
For a driver who comes back clean, Tennessee does provide one remedy. Under Tenn. Code Ann. § 40-32-101, the public records of a dismissed charge are “removed and destroyed without cost to the person” when the person petitions the court. The TBI says charges that were dismissed, nolle prosequi, no true bill, or not guilty are eligible for expungement at no cost to the defendant. tn
Expungement doesn’t address the rest of what an arrest costs. It doesn’t repay the defense lawyer, the bond, or the tow and impound fees. It doesn’t cover lost work time or remove the mugshot from websites that have already copied it. WSMV reported that Raybin said Tennessee gives sober drivers no way to recoup costs, even after DUI charges are dismissed, so suing is their only option. Another driver WSMV profiled, cleared after a Wilson County crash arrest, said she paid her attorney several thousand dollars. Raybin described the damage to Fair as more than financial: “Stefanie suffered tremendous harm from having her mugshot and the description of the incident all over the internet.” wsmv
That leaves a cleared driver two options: absorb the costs or sue. Raybin told WSMV, “I think that the state has recognized that a lot of these arrests are just completely legally unsupportable,” and said a jury would likely have ruled against the state. He said in a separate statement that the arrest “never should have happened,” but that the State “has taken a measure of accountability by approving the settlement.” The $70,000 comes from state funds. Velez isn’t paying it, and neither are troopers generally. oxygen
How many sober drivers Tennessee has arrested, and why the count exists
Tennessee has a count of these arrests because its legislature required one. Senate Bill 1166, which became Public Chapter 327 in 2025, requires the TBI to report each year to the House and Senate speakers every DUI arrest under § 55-10-401 where no alcohol or other intoxicants were found in the driver’s blood or breath. The law also requires the report to name the agency that made each arrest. The TBA Law Blog reported that the bill passed both chambers unanimously, with reporting set to run through 2029.
The first report under the law showed the scale. According to WBIR, of the 16,883 blood samples submitted to the TBI’s lab in 2024, 419 Tennessee drivers were charged with DUI despite not testing positive for drugs or alcohol. WSMV’s analysis of the same data found that the Tennessee Highway Patrol accounted for 180 of those arrests, more than any other agency, and that Nashville had 37. The TBI added a caveat in its report: it calibrates breath instruments but doesn’t administer breath tests, so its numbers come only from blood samples sent to its labs. wbir
Each of those 419 went through what Fair did: arrested first, cleared by a lab later. That’s about 2.5% of the blood samples the TBI tested that year. On the 2024 figures, the Highway Patrol was involved in more than four in ten of those arrests.
The other lawsuits against the Highway Patrol and one trooper
Fair’s settlement follows one other. Thomas Manis received $75,000 after state troopers arrested him for DUI in East Tennessee. More suits are pending. NASA employee Labreesha Batey and former U.S. attorney Jane Bondurant are both suing the state. One trooper appears repeatedly: WSMV reported that Trooper James Zahn is accused of arresting nine sober drivers. Bondurant was his eighth, and a Thompson Station man’s lawsuit filed this year would make him the ninth. Those claims are allegations in pending lawsuits, and none has been decided. The problem isn’t limited to the Highway Patrol either: the Rutherford County Sheriff’s Office and La Vergne police have also settled lawsuits from sober drivers arrested for DUI. wsmv
Related Articles
- A Chicopee Chase Hit 86 MPH in a 35 Zone, a Passenger’s Suit Alleges. Then the Car Hit a House and a 13-Year-Old Died
- HPD Officer Hit Her Car, Then Houston Sold It for $10
Two settlements totaling $145,000 is not much for a state budget. But the state is choosing to settle instead of defending these arrests in court, and the pending cases have the same basic facts as Fair’s: a trooper’s observations, an arrest, and a clean lab result months later. The 2025 reporting law adds another factor. Every new clean result is now listed by agency in a report delivered to the House and Senate speakers. That data is likely to show up in lawsuits as evidence of a pattern.
What comes next for Fair and for drivers stopped in Tennessee
Fair’s payment is due within weeks, according to the attorney general’s office. The Batey, Bondurant, and Thompson Station cases are still pending. The next TBI report, covering 2025 arrests, is due to the legislature by Jan. 1, 2027. That report will be the first to show whether the Highway Patrol’s numbers changed after the 2024 publicity.
For drivers, the law hasn’t changed. A Tennessee trooper can still arrest you for DUI based on observations, and the blood result that might clear you can take months. If the charge is dismissed, you can have the record expunged at no cost, but you have to petition the court for it. If you want the arrest costs back, you have to sue.
Tennessee pays sober drivers like Fair only when they sue and the state decides to settle. If a trooper said he smelled alcohol on you tomorrow, could you front a lawyer and a bond for two months while the lab caught up?
