Chicopee, Mass., is defending a second lawsuit over a March 2023 police chase that ended inside a house on Montgomery Street.
Branden Bynum, who was 17 and in the car, says officers Kyle Robbins and Aaron Beaulieu kept after a vehicle doing 86 mph in a 35 zone, according to MassLive’s reporting on the complaint. MassLive reported that the suit was filed in Hampden Superior Court in October and that the city had it moved to federal court the week the story ran. The complaint says Bynum’s spine was fractured. A 13-year-old boy in the same car could not be freed before it was engulfed in flames and died at the scene, the Hampden District Attorney’s Office said.
What the Hampden DA’s office said happened
The DA’s April 2023 release puts the crash at about 2:43 a.m. on Saturday, March 25, 2023. Chicopee police saw a car traveling at a high rate of speed on Broadway, followed it onto Montgomery Street and tried to stop it, and the car sped off north. An officer later found it in the 1000 block of Montgomery after it had struck a house’s exterior wall and come to rest inside. The car caught fire, and the fire spread through the residence. Four people were in the car, and a resident in the room the car hit was seriously injured.
The DA’s office charged the 19-year-old driver with OUI manslaughter, OUI causing serious bodily injury and unlicensed operation. He was arraigned April 20, 2023, in Chicopee District Court, and bail was set at $50,000 cash. Those are accusations, and I could not find a published disposition of the case.
What the complaint claims
I could not retrieve the complaint itself, so the claims below are as MassLive described them. It accuses Robbins and Beaulieu of violating Bynum’s due process rights by continuing the pursuit despite the growing risk of a catastrophic crash when they had time to choose a safer course. It accuses unnamed supervisors of failing to train officers or stop the chase, and it accuses the city of negligence. It says Chicopee’s pursuit policy told officers to weigh the danger of a chase against the need to detain a suspect immediately. MassLive also reported that Robbins testified he had no training on vehicle pursuits, and that the complaint says the Harwich police department let him go, citing difficulty responding to training.
The city’s lawyer, Cole Fahrenkopf, argued the officers have qualified immunity because they did not violate established law, and that they pursued for only a brief time before losing sight of the car, MassLive reported. The DA’s account of an officer finding the car after the crash fits the city’s version, but a press release does not say how long the chase ran or how far. How long the chase ran is the number both sides need.
Why chase suits against officers are hard to win
The Supreme Court set the bar in County of Sacramento v. Lewis, decided May 26, 1998. A deputy chased a motorcycle at speeds up to about 100 mph, and his patrol car struck and killed the 16-year-old passenger. The Court held that an officer in a chase violates substantive due process only with a purpose to cause harm unrelated to the legitimate aim of making an arrest. Negligence does not meet that standard. Neither does deliberate indifference, which can be enough in settings like pretrial detention but, the Court said, not in a sudden pursuit where officers make split-second calls.
Set against that, the complaint’s language about officers who had time to choose a safer course looks aimed at the line between a split-second decision and a deliberate one. That is my read of the claim as MassLive described it, not a quotation from the complaint. The city’s argument that the chase was brief pushes the other way. The negligence count against the city does not depend on proving anyone meant harm, though the city can raise its own defenses to it.
The tequila count against J&J Package Store
J&J Package Store is a defendant on the claim that it sold two bottles of tequila to the 19-year-old driver without checking his ID. The complaint alleges the driver was intoxicated after leaving a birthday gathering in Springfield, headed toward Holyoke. Massachusetts law, M.G.L. c. 138, § 34, makes selling alcohol to anyone under 21 a crime punishable by a fine of up to $2,000, up to a year in jail, or both. The section’s text does not mention checking ID, so whether a clerk asked is a fact the store can contest. MassLive’s account does not include a response from the store.
What happens next in Chicopee
A resident who was sleeping on his couch when the car came through the wall was injured and filed an earlier suit against the city and its officers. In May, the city’s lawyer asked a judge to dismiss it, MassLive reported, and its account gives no ruling. With Bynum’s case now in federal court, the first thing to watch is whether the officers’ qualified-immunity argument is decided before anyone is deposed about how long the chase lasted.
The suit says the car was doing 86 in a 35. The Supreme Court’s bar for suing over a chase is intent to harm. Is that the right bar when a 13-year-old dies?
