File photo of a marked Utah Highway Patrol sedan; not the vehicle involved in the Nov. 15 crash. Photo: An Errant Knight / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
A Utah Highway Patrol trooper put his patrol car in the path of a Subaru on the US-40 ramp to westbound I-80 in Summit County, near Park City, at about 6:37 a.m. on Sunday, Nov. 15, and the Subaru hit it, according to the Utah Department of Public Safety.
The ramp was fully closed because of an earlier two-vehicle crash. DPS said the Subaru’s driver went around the traffic cones, passed marked emergency vehicles with their lights on, and kept going toward the first crash scene, where responders were working. Two troopers riding together were warned by radio that the Subaru was coming at about 45 mph. The trooper driving steered into its path, and the Subaru struck the passenger side of the patrol car. Both troopers and the Subaru’s driver, who was alone, went to a hospital with non-life-threatening injuries, and DPS said the troopers have since been released. The agency called the trooper’s “quick, selfless decision” one that prevented further injuries and possibly deaths among the people working the first scene.
The charges so far are misdemeanors, by one station’s count
Summit County Sheriff’s Office deputies investigated and booked the driver, a 30-year-old man, into the Summit County Jail for DUI, DPS said. KUTV, citing police documents, reported a breath-test reading of .169, which the station described as more than three times Utah’s legal limit, and said a records search found no prior DUI charges for him. A second KUTV report said he faces three misdemeanor counts: negligently operating a vehicle resulting in injury, failure to observe a barricade, and DUI. KPCW reported Monday evening that he had been released from jail Sunday and had not been charged at that point.
Backfire News could not obtain a charging document or a court docket, so the counts above are KUTV’s account, and the .169 is a police-report number relayed by KUTV, not a lab result or a court finding. Another KUTV story described the charges as including DUI and speeding, so the list may not be settled. A charge is an accusation. No statement from the driver or an attorney appeared in any report I reviewed.
Where Utah’s felony line sits for DUI injuries
Utah’s per se limit is .05, not the .08 used in most states, and Utah Code 41-6a-502 makes an ordinary violation a class B misdemeanor. A .169 reading is about 3.4 times the Utah limit, by Backfire News’s arithmetic. The blood-alcohol number sets the DUI count. The injuries decide whether anything above a misdemeanor is possible.
The Utah Courts’ statutory overview of DUI law lists a third-degree felony for DUI that causes serious bodily injury, under Section 41-6a-503. The DUI chapter defines serious bodily injury as bodily injury that creates or causes serious permanent disfigurement, protracted loss or impairment of a bodily function, or a substantial risk of death. The same overview says a driver is guilty of a separate offense for each victim who suffers bodily injury, serious bodily injury or death, even when the injuries come from one episode of driving. Two injured troopers can therefore mean two counts, whatever the grade.
DPS called the troopers’ injuries non-life-threatening and said both were released. KUTV reported, from the police report, possible broken ribs and a hip injury for one trooper. Whether that meets the statute’s definition is a question for the prosecutor and, if it comes to it, a court. None of the reports I reviewed includes a prosecutor explaining the counts.
A closed ramp is not a move-over case
Utah’s move-over statute, Section 41-6a-904, covers a stationary emergency vehicle showing flashing lights: the driver must slow down and give as much space as practical, and a violation is an infraction. In the version effective in May 2023, a violation also carries a four-hour defensive driving course, with a 90-day license suspension if the course isn’t completed in time. The reports on this case list failure to observe a barricade, not that statute. DPS says the Subaru went around the cones that closed the ramp.
What to watch in Summit County
No court date appeared in the reports. A filed charging document will show which counts prosecutors chose, whether they match what KUTV described, and whether the injuries to the troopers are charged as bodily injury or as something less. DPS said troopers are recovering at home.
DPS says a trooper steered into the Subaru to protect the crews at the first crash. One trooper had possible broken ribs and a hip injury. Is that a felony for the driver, or does “serious” mean more than that?
