A 2003 BMW 525i (E39) shown as a file photo; it is not Christian Henry's car. Photo: Charles from Port Chester, New York via Wikimedia Commons (CC0)
Christian Henry started the fall semester at East Carolina University in Greenville, N.C., with one purple paper clip. He finished with a 2003 BMW, and if that title changes hands, North Carolina wants its 3%.
The car is the last stop in a class assignment. WNCT reported that the Purple Paperclip Challenge is part of a negotiation course taught by Dr. Leah Grubb, in which students were given a purple paper clip at the start of the semester and tasked with trading it for progressively larger items. Henry, a business management major, finished with the BMW. WNCT said classmates ended up with an Apple Watch, a guitar and an e-bike.

The trade chain, as reported
WBTV reported this sequence, dating Henry’s first TikTok video to Aug. 19:
- Paper clip for a bottle of White-Out, within 24 hours of the first video
- White-Out for a Roku TV remote, inside the same 24 hours
- The remote for an electric drill
- The drill for a fishing rod, with all four trades done within a week of the challenge starting
- The fishing rod for a Fender guitar, a week and a half later
- The guitar for a 2003 BMW, which WBTV attributed to WNCT and said had not yet been posted on TikTok
Henry’s account, @christian.paperclip, carries six videos, the first dated Aug. 19 and the latest Aug. 31. The bio says the next video arrives at Thanksgiving, and WBTV wrote that it will presumably show the guitar-for-car trade.
@christian.paperclip The beginning‼️ #paperclipchallenge
Video: Christian Henry (@christian.paperclip) on TikTok, posted Aug. 19.
Which BMW, and what it is worth
The reports disagree on the car. WBTV called it a 525i. WCTI reported a 328i. WNCT’s story says only 2003 BMW, and WBTV gives the same year. WCTI gives no model year. I could not find a title, listing or other record that settles the model.
The value is also reported two ways. WCTI put the project’s gain at $2,000, or roughly 40,000 times the value of the clip. WBTV cited Kelley Blue Book at just under $3,000 for a typical 2003 525i.
What North Carolina charges on a car that cost a guitar
Moving a car between owners takes a title transfer. NCDMV says a person buying, selling, gifting or donating a vehicle has to transfer it that way, that both the original owner and the recipient complete the back of the original title, and that North Carolina titles must be notarized.
The tax comes with the title. NCDMV says the state collects a highway-use tax instead of sales tax whenever a title is transferred. Under G.S. 105-187.3 the rate is 3%, and when the seller is not a dealer the statute taxes the vehicle’s market value, presumed to be the figure in a schedule the Commissioner of Motor Vehicles adopts. Those schedule values may not exceed wholesale values in a recognized automotive reference. The state’s fee sheet, form MVR-106, revised April 2026, says the same thing in shorter form: on a casual sale, 3% of the “computer value” of the vehicle. A dealer sale is taxed on the sales price instead. For a private deal, what the buyer gave up, whether cash or a guitar, is not the tax base.
The arithmetic below is mine, not NCDMV’s. Three percent of $3,000 is $90, and because the schedule cannot exceed wholesale, the tax on a 23-year-old BMW in that range should come in under that. The same form lists a certificate of title at $66.75. NCDMV also says vehicles carry property taxes that it collects for counties.
The exemptions are family transfers. NCDMV lists gifts between spouses, parent and child, and stepparent and stepchild as exempt, using form MVR-613. A trade with someone outside the family is not on it.
The red paper clip came first
Canadian blogger Kyle MacDonald ran the original version. CBC reported in 2006 that it took him almost a year and 14 trades to turn one red paper clip into the offer of a two-storey farmhouse in Kipling, Saskatchewan. Henry’s chain, at least six trades by WBTV’s count, ended in a car within one semester. Trades run the other direction too: someone once swapped an Audi R8 for $130,000 in Pokémon cards.
What happens next
None of the three reports says whether the title has been transferred, what figure NCDMV assigned the car, or whether the previous owner was a dealer or a private seller. Those answers decide which tax rule applied and how much Henry paid. The Thanksgiving video is the next place to look.
The state taxes Henry on a book value, not the Fender he handed over. What’s the strangest thing you’ve traded toward a car?
