An Idaho collector’s horse won Best in Show at the Route 66 Model Horse Show in Tigard, Oregon, her first such win. The next day, someone smashed the back window of her rental car in downtown Portland. She said about 100 custom, artist resin and original finish models were taken from the rental sometime Saturday night or Sunday morning, and she put the collection’s value at about $10,000. Many of the horses were about 3 inches tall.
The Portland Police Bureau’s account begins the next morning. On Sunday, Nov. 8, 2026, at 11:40 a.m., an officer responded to a car prowl near Southwest Harvey Milk Street and Southwest 10th Avenue. The parked, unoccupied rental had been broken into overnight. She told The Oregonian why the horses were in the car at all. She had parked just after 9 p.m. and left the collection in the car because she didn’t feel safe carrying it. She said it “would have required both hands.”
Witnesses say the horses were handed out near Powell’s
Within a day, the models began showing up in the hands of strangers. She said a security guard told her he saw a man handing out the horses near Powell’s Books, by the Green Room entrance at 10th and West Burnside. A guard near Powell’s told KPTV they recognized a man giving away green knit pouches near the bookstore and confirmed the pouches held her model horses. According to her account to The Oregonian, the guard also said the man had been seen handing out piles of the horses and selling them for $5. That $5 figure comes to us thirdhand, through the guard and then through her. It’s set against $10,000 for about 100 models, or roughly $100 apiece, based on her own estimate.
Related Articles
- Avril Lavigne’s Car Collection: What’s Confirmed, What’s Rumored, and What’s a Skateboard
- A D.C. Man Allegedly Reprogrammed Fobs on Maryland Dealer Corvettes and Drove Off Without Paying. Feds Added a Gun Count
Police arrested a suspect on Wednesday. According to the bureau, Central Precinct’s Neighborhood Response Team identified a man seen trying to sell or give away the figurines and arrested Benjamin T. Moore, 39, on Nov. 11, 2026. He was booked into the Multnomah County Detention Center on five counts of theft by receiving, one count of second-degree theft, and two outstanding warrants. These are booking charges. The Multnomah County District Attorney decides what gets filed, and I found no public record of a charging decision or a defense statement as of Nov. 16. Moore is presumed innocent.
The bureau also drew a line in its release: “As of now, he has not been charged related to the original theft.”
The charges cover the horses, not the broken window
Oregon law treats smashing a window to steal from a car and passing the stolen items around afterward as separate crimes, and so far the booking sheet covers only the second. Under ORS 164.272, a person commits unlawful entry into a motor vehicle by entering one with intent to commit a crime. It’s a Class A misdemeanor. To charge it, prosecutors have to put a specific person inside a specific car. A man handing out horses outside a bookstore the next day doesn’t prove that by itself.
Theft by receiving covers the after-the-fact handling. Under ORS 164.095, it means receiving, retaining, concealing, or disposing of someone else’s property while “knowing or having good reason to know” it was stolen. This is why police can make an arrest in a car-prowl case without solving the car prowl. They trace the property, because the property has witnesses and the broken window usually doesn’t.
The degree of the charge also says something. Second-degree theft applies when the property’s total value “in a single or aggregate transaction is $100 or more and less than $1,000,” and it’s a Class A misdemeanor. First-degree theft starts at $1,000 and is a Class C felony. The collection was worth about $10,000 by its owner’s estimate, but the booking charge was for less than $1,000. Charges follow what investigators can tie to one person, not the size of the loss. Oregon’s valuation statute, ORS 164.115, lets single theft transactions be added together when they’re committed within a one-year period, so the dollar figure, and with it a possible felony, could change once the DA reviews the case.
The “good reason to know” standard also reaches beyond the man police arrested. Someone who accepted a hand-painted horse in a knit pouch from a stranger on West Burnside is now holding property that police and local TV have publicly described as stolen.
The owner’s publicity recovered most of the horses
Police did not recover any horses when they arrested the suspect. The large recovery came three days later from a tip. The bureau said officers recovered 72 figurines on Saturday, Nov. 14, after a public tip that came in once the victim had publicized the theft on social media and in news interviews. Some figurines are going straight back to the owner, and roughly three dozen are still unaccounted for.
Before that, she was recovering horses one at a time. She got one back from a Powell’s employee, police received two from people who had been handed or sold models, and she said she had leads on eight more. She also told owners how to avoid being scammed. She asked anyone holding a model to contact Portland police first to avoid scams or ransom demands, and said she would pay shipping and reimburse anyone who had bought one.
Related Articles
- Toyota Launched the A90 Supra at Auction and Is Sending the Last One Off the Same Way. VIN 99999 Funds Paul Walker’s Charity
- Red Bull’s Bryce Menzies and Christopher Polvoorde Go From Baja 1000 Teammates to Rivals
Car prowls are routine in Portland. These goods came with tags carrying her name and regional collector number, #1001, and rode in blue and orange pouches decorated with goldfish. A laptop taken from a rental car doesn’t come with a hobby community that recognizes it on sight.
Who pays for the missing three dozen
Neither the rental company nor auto insurance is likely to pay for the horses. According to Progressive’s coverage guidance, personal property stolen from a car isn’t covered by auto insurance but is likely covered under a home, renters, or condo policy. The car is handled separately. Oregon’s insurance regulator has advised that the coverage you carry on your own car is the coverage you have on a rental, and that rental companies sell collision damage waivers to shift damage liability to the rental company. So a smashed window and stolen belongings can mean two claims, two deductibles, and possibly a separate fee from the rental counter. Whether a homeowners policy will pay full value for one-of-a-kind resin art, or whether it needs a separately scheduled collectibles rider, depends on the policy.
What comes next in the Portland case
The bureau says Central Precinct’s Neighborhood Response Team is continuing the investigation. Anyone with information about the car prowl or the missing figurines can email crimetips@police.portlandoregon.gov, attn: Central NRT, and reference case number 26-324486. Two decisions are next: whether the DA files the theft counts as booked or combines their values, and whether anyone is ever charged with the break-in itself. If no one is, the window that started all this will stay a Class A misdemeanor nobody answered for.
About two-thirds of the herd made it back to Idaho, and nobody has been charged for the window. If it were your collection, would you want police chasing the person who broke in or the people holding the horses?
Sources: kptv.com, portland.gov, spokesman.com, katu.com, oregonlegislature.gov, embed.clearimpact.com, progressive.com, webarchive.library.unt.edu.
