File photo of a 2018 Nissan Frontier, the model FHP says was involved. It is not the vehicle in the crash. Photo: Bull-Doser/Wikimedia Commons, public domain
A pickup that Florida Highway Patrol says ran a red light at State Road 19 and Guerrant Street in Umatilla, Florida, killed a 44-year-old woman at about 4:20 a.m. on Nov. 9, and its 26-year-old driver is now charged with vehicular homicide and with fleeing police resulting in injury or death. FOX 35 Orlando reported she was a mother of two. Charges are accusations, and I found no statement from a defense attorney and no court filing in the reporting so far.
FHP said the 2018 Nissan Frontier was heading south on State Road 19 when it hit the left side of the woman’s 2019 Jeep Cherokee, which was eastbound on Guerrant Street. Inside Lake reported that the Jeep driver died at the scene and the pickup driver was taken to a Sanford hospital with serious injuries. FHP Lt. Tara Crescenzi told Inside Lake on Nov. 11 that he was still in intensive care and would be booked into the Lake County Jail after his release, according to that report.
What Umatilla police say happened
Umatilla Police Chief David Seeley told FOX 35 that an officer clocked the pickup at 60 mph in a 30 mph zone and turned on emergency lights, and that there was no time to start a chase before the crash. FHP also gave the 60-in-a-30 figure, per the same FOX 35 report. The department’s Nov. 10 timeline, as WESH reported it, says the officer first radioed a traffic stop and about six seconds later reported the truck fleeing and crashed. The department said the officer slowed down instead of pursuing.
FOX 35 reported that surveillance video from Umatilla City Hall appears to show the light turn green for the Jeep before the pickup ran the red. The station also reported that dense fog kept authorities from airlifting the pickup driver.
The stolen-truck claim has changed
The felony murder talk rested on the theft. Seeley told FOX 35 the driver could face felony murder because the truck was stolen, and FHP’s first account described the Frontier as reported stolen. A day later, Umatilla police said the officer had no evidence the truck was stolen when he tried to stop it, according to Inside Lake, and WESH reported the department said the stop began over the truck’s speed. None of the reporting I found says when, or by whom, the Frontier was reported stolen, and I have not seen a theft report.
What Florida’s felony murder law lists
Florida’s felony murder statute, section 782.04(3), makes a killing during certain listed felonies second-degree murder, a first-degree felony punishable by up to life. The list covers arson, robbery, burglary, kidnapping and carjacking, among others. Motor vehicle theft is not on it. Aggravated fleeing or eluding with serious bodily injury or death is. If prosecutors ever wanted a murder count, the route would run through the flight from the officer, not through whether the truck was stolen.
That flight offense is defined in section 316.1935. Fleeing a marked patrol vehicle with lights and siren on, at high speed or with wanton disregard for safety, and causing death, is a first-degree felony with a three-year mandatory minimum and no early release before that minimum is served. A court must also revoke the driver’s license for one to five years after a conviction. Vehicular homicide, section 782.071, is a second-degree felony in its base form. The reporting does not give statute numbers for the charges FHP listed, so matching them to these sections is my reading, and no murder count has been reported.
The driver’s reported record
Inside Lake, citing Lake County court records and the Florida Department of Corrections, reported that the driver pleaded no contest in December 2025 to two counts of fleeing or attempting to elude, plus motor vehicle theft, fentanyl possession and driving with a suspended license. The outlet reported that corrections records show him leaving prison on Aug. 18, 2026, less than three months before the crash, and that a July 2025 case involved a reported-stolen Lexus that he fled in. I have not pulled those court files myself.
The driver hasn’t been booked yet
The driver has not yet been booked, so a first appearance, bond decision and formal charging document are still ahead. The open questions: do prosecutors stay with vehicular homicide and fleeing or add a murder count, and does the stolen-truck story ever land in a court filing instead of a news conference? FHP’s written policy lets troopers use a PIT maneuver at any speed. Umatilla’s officer slowed down.
By the department’s own timeline, about six seconds separated the stop call from the crash report. Should Umatilla’s officer have backed off at all, or kept the truck in sight?
