Photo: Damian B Oh / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0
Police in Grand Forks, North Dakota, say a man who admitted he had been drinking drove a stolen 2016 Audi TT into the east side of a house at about 11:29 p.m. on Oct. 27. The car also hit a natural gas line and a city street sign, and gas leaked while officers and firefighters evacuated the surrounding houses, according to the officer’s declaration of probable cause as reported by Valley News Live.
Officers pulled the driver from the seat, the declaration says. On Nov. 10, charges were filed in Grand Forks County District Court: theft of property valued at $10,000 to $50,000, a Class B felony; reckless endangerment with extreme indifference and knowingly contacting an emergency responder with bodily fluids, both Class C felonies; criminal mischief, a Class A misdemeanor; and first-offense DUI at 0.08% or greater and driving under suspension, both Class B misdemeanors. He is in the Grand Forks County Jail. These are allegations, he is presumed innocent, and the Valley News Live report carried no statement from a defense attorney.
Three of the six counts are felonies, and the DUI isn’t one of them. Theft is a felony because the Audi was worth about $16,000. Spitting is a felony because the charge says he did it knowingly; the paramedic’s eye was irritated. Endangerment becomes one only if prosecutors can show extreme indifference to human life. The house, structural damage and all, got a misdemeanor.
Why the car’s value drives the top charge
The owner told police he did not know the driver, never gave him permission, and that the car was taken from another home. He valued it at about $16,000. Under North Dakota’s theft grading statute, section 12.1-23-05, value above $10,000 and not above $50,000 is a Class B felony, which the state’s sentencing classifications cap at ten years in prison and a $20,000 fine. The grade follows what was taken, not what happened afterward. The same $16,000 car parked undamaged in a driveway would have been the same Class B felony.
The next section, 12.1-23-06, covers unauthorized use of a vehicle. It is a Class C felony when the value of the use plus the cost of retrieving and restoring the vehicle exceeds $1,000, and a Class A misdemeanor otherwise. The complaint charged theft.
How the house damage is charged
Valley News Live reported significant structural damage to the house. The charge for it is criminal mischief, a Class A misdemeanor, which carries up to 360 days and a $3,000 fine. Under section 12.1-21-05, the felony tiers require intentionally causing loss over $2,000. Recklessly causing a loss over $2,000, or intentionally causing $100 to $2,000, is a Class A misdemeanor. The reporting does not say which of those applies, and no repair estimate has been published, so what the homeowner is out is not on the record.
The charging grade does not set what the homeowner can recover. After a conviction, section 12.1-32-08 lets the court order restitution for losses that are reasonable, directly related to the offense, and actually sustained. If the court keeps jurisdiction over the claim, the victim files an affidavit with supporting documents, the prosecutor serves it on the defendant within 60 days after sentencing, and the defendant has 30 days to ask for a hearing. A restitution order can be enforced like a civil judgment, and anything paid is deducted from civil damages for the same incident. The statute does not mention private insurers.
The spitting count and the DUI count
Officers smelled alcohol on the driver in the ambulance and noted bloodshot, watery eyes and slurred speech, the declaration says, and he told paramedics he had been drinking. It also says he spit on a paramedic and some of it got in the paramedic’s eye, leaving it irritated. Section 12.1-17-11 lists saliva among the fluids covered and protects law enforcement officers, health care facility workers and emergency responders. Knowingly causing the contact is a Class C felony, up to five years and $10,000. Doing it recklessly is a Class A misdemeanor, so the word “knowingly” in the charge is what makes it a felony.
The reckless endangerment count is a Class C felony only when the circumstances show extreme indifference to the value of human life, under section 12.1-17-03. Without that finding it is a Class A misdemeanor.
The DUI is the lightest count. A first offense under section 39-08-01 is a Class B misdemeanor: a minimum $500 fine, an addiction evaluation, and no mandatory jail unless the concentration is 0.16 or higher. The statutory maximum is 30 days and $1,500. The per se standard is a chemical test of 0.08 within two hours of driving. Police obtained a warrant for a blood sample at the hospital, and the declaration as reported gives no result.
What happens next
Add the felony maximums and you get 20 years: ten for the Class B theft, five for each Class C. That’s a ceiling, not a forecast. The reports reviewed list no bail amount or court date, so the first appearance and whether a blood result appears in the file are the next things to watch. If there is a conviction, the homeowner’s repair bills would come back up through the restitution process, 60 days after sentencing.
A $16,000 car stolen and parked undamaged in a driveway is the same Class B felony as this one. Should North Dakota grade car theft by the sticker price or by the damage?
