On Aug. 30, a Cars and Coffee meetup was breaking up in La Honda, California, in the San Mateo County mountains. A Tesla Model Y left the event with a 21-year-old Tesla employee driving and two photographers riding along. Minutes later it crossed the double yellow line on Highway 84 and hit a Honda head-on. The lawsuit was filed by Michelle Brooks of Loma Mar. It names Tesla, the driver (identified as Micah Zuglian), the racing meetup group 9burgring and its founder, Ethan Garabedian, and the Ambassador Wine Bar as defendants. The lawsuit was filed Thursday in San Mateo County Superior Court, nearly three months after the Aug. 30 crash. San Francisco Chronicle nbcbayarea
Brooks is 70. According to NBC Bay Area’s report on the filing, the complaint lists a traumatic brain injury, fractured vertebrae and ribs, broken limbs and internal injuries.
Related Articles
- A Charlotte Cop Allegedly Ran 1 Plate Through Flock for a Friend, and the Phone Search Turned Up a Group Text Tied to 6 More Officers
- Ford’s Cobra Teaser Has No Car in It, Just a V8 Pulling Through the Gears and the Words “All-Motor Heart.” The Rest Waits Until 2027
The 83 mph figure doesn’t come only from the lawsuit. One of the people in the Tesla recorded it. Whether the driver was working for Tesla at that moment will largely decide how much Tesla can be made to pay, because California caps what a car’s owner owes for a crash unless the driver was doing the owner’s business.
What the passenger’s video shows
Garabedian, the event organizer and owner of 9burgring, provided the footage. It was recorded on a cellphone by one of two photographers he had hired. The photographers were reportedly offered a ride in the Tesla as the event ended, and Garabedian said the driver may not have known he was being recorded. In the video, the Tesla accelerates through curves and a construction zone, at one point reaching 83 mph. You can hear a warning chime as the speedometer nears 85 mph. The posted limit on that section is 35 to 40 mph. Investigative Unit +2
The Tesla swerves through a series of mountain curves. Then the driver appears to lose control, crosses the center lines and hits a Honda coming the other way head-on. Besides the Honda’s 70-year-old driver, at least two of the Tesla’s passengers were taken to the hospital. nbcbayareanbcbayarea
The video doesn’t settle who is legally at fault. In NBC Bay Area’s September report, the California Highway Patrol was still investigating. It identified the Tesla driver as a 21-year-old man who crossed into oncoming traffic but had not made a final fault determination. That report mentioned no arrest or citation, and I found no public record of criminal charges. The claims against Zuglian and Tesla are allegations in a civil complaint that no court has tested. nbcbayarea
Whether the driver was on Tesla’s clock
Brooks’s case against Tesla rests on a California rule that runs inside every car loan and fleet policy. Under Vehicle Code section 17150, a car’s owner is liable for crashes caused by anyone driving it with permission. Section 17151 then limits that liability. The limit applies to an owner’s liability that does not arise through the relationship of principal and agent or master and servant, and it is $15,000 for injury to one person and $30,000 for injury to more than one person in any one accident. publicfindlaw
If the employee had borrowed the car on a day off, Tesla’s liability as owner would stop at $15,000 for Brooks, which wouldn’t cover much treatment for a traumatic brain injury. If he was acting as Tesla’s agent, Civil Code section 2338 makes the company responsible for his negligence in the course of its business, with no cap.
The complaint is written around that second possibility. It says Zuglian was representing Tesla at the event and driving a company-owned Model Y when he offered two photographers a ride. It also alleges that Tesla was negligent in its own right, including by allowing an unfit driver to operate the vehicle. That second claim is a negligent-entrustment theory. It asks what Tesla knew about the person it gave the keys to, separately from what he did with them. Brooks’s attorney, Niall McCarthy, noted that the car was registered to Tesla, suggesting the company had chosen “to market its cars at a racing club in an area that’s infamous for street racing.” Woman injured in Highway 84 crash sues Tesla, car event organizers over alleged negligence
Tesla hasn’t said publicly whether the ride was company business. It did not respond to NBC Bay Area’s request for comment in September or say whether the driver was working for the company. Garabedian said Tesla was a vendor at the event and that a company representative was driving the car. In court, Tesla can argue that taking two photographers for a fast drive after the event ended was outside the job. A sales representative showing off a company car to people photographing the event is a hard ride to call personal. nbcbayarea
Warnings to the organizers before the event
The organizers face a different problem. A host is usually harder to blame than an employer for what a guest does after leaving the lot. Brooks’s lawyers are relying on the warnings. The complaint alleges the organizers and the venue were negligent in going ahead despite warnings from local authorities about traffic hazards. McCarthy told NBC Bay Area: “We had the San Mateo Sheriff show up say, don’t have the event.” nbcbayareanbcbayarea
San Mateo County Supervisor Ray Mueller backs that account. He said the event should not have happened and that his office had tried to discourage the organizer. He also said CHP and the Sheriff’s Department were at the event at his request, and volunteers handed out safety flyers. His message for Tesla was “Train your drivers better, this is just unacceptable.” nbcbayarea
Garabedian has defended the meetup. “We don’t condone any recklessness—or donuts, burnouts, revving, anything,” he said, adding, “We’re here to have a safe event.” He said the event was meant to promote the Ambassador Wine Garden, whose owner had asked his company to organize it. The Ambassador Wine Garden did not respond to requests for comment. nbcbayarea
Highway 84’s crash record and the camera law
La Honda residents have been complaining about this road for a long time. California Highway Patrol crash data from UC Berkeley’s Transportation Injury Mapping System show that over the past five years, 21 people were killed and 792 were injured on highways 84, 35 and 9 in San Mateo County. NBC Bay Area noted that those figures don’t show how many of the crashes involved speeding or street racing. nbcbayarea
Related Articles
- A New Jersey Powerball Ticket’s $363.1M Cash Value Could Buy McQueen’s Ferrari, Senna’s Williams and Vegas’s Top 8 Sales With $269M+ Left
- A Corvette Stolen Oct. 1 Turned Up in a Silver Spring Driveway 32 Days Later. Cops Say a Dallas Man Hit an Officer With a Privately Made Gun
The county’s main tool for catching speeders doesn’t reach the area under current law. San Mateo County is looking into whether La Honda and nearby communities could join California’s speed-camera pilot program. The law that created that program, AB 645, authorizes speed cameras until January 1, 2032, in the cities of Los Angeles, San Jose, Oakland, Glendale and Long Beach and the City and County of San Francisco. La Honda is unincorporated county land, so adding it would take a new bill in Sacramento. The county has a nearer-term plan. Mueller said he expects the county to approve funding for an extra CHP patrol on highways 84 and 35 on weekends, when residents say speeding and high-performance driving are most common. Investigative Unit
Tesla is also facing another test-drive lawsuit. In Virginia, a woman claims Tesla is responsible for injuries she suffered in a 2024 crash while test-driving a Model Y in Arlington; she alleges the car had been set to its “Insane” acceleration mode without her knowledge. [Internal link: Auto Wire coverage of the Arlington test-drive lawsuit.] The two cases have different facts. Both raise the same question about what a carmaker owes the public when its staff hand out drives in fast cars. fox5sandiego
What happens next in San Mateo County court
Tesla, Zuglian, Garabedian and the wine bar will each file responses, and the CHP’s final report on fault is still pending. The first fight in court will likely be over the scope of Zuglian’s job. If the ride was Tesla business, Brooks can pursue her full damages from a company that can pay them. If it wasn’t, California’s 1967-era cap leaves her mainly with a claim against a 21-year-old driver.
When a company’s employee takes a company car to a car meet and gives strangers a ride, should the company be fully liable for how that ride is driven, or should the $15,000 owner’s cap apply unless the employee was under orders?
