A routine stolen-vehicle call in West Virginia turned deadly Thursday afternoon when a driver fleeing deputies in a stolen SUV slammed into another car on Interstate 64, killing a woman who had no connection to the pursuit whatsoever.
How The Chase Started
Around 2:37 p.m., deputies received a report that the suspect might be armed. About ten minutes later, they located the stolen SUV — a 2025 Jeep Cherokee — and attempted a traffic stop. Instead of pulling over, the driver, identified by deputies as 22-year-old Joseph R. Elswick Jr., accelerated away, weaving across roadways before steering onto Interstate 64 eastbound near Milton and pushing the pursuit into triple-digit speeds on a highway full of uninvolved drivers.
Deputies deployed spike strips near mile marker 34. The Jeep hit them at full speed, shredding its tires, but kept going for another half mile on ruined rubber. At that speed, blown tires leave a driver with almost no real steering or braking control — effectively turning the vehicle into something no one behind the wheel can reliably aim.
An Uninvolved Driver Killed
Elswick lost control in live traffic and struck the car of 52-year-old Angela Born, who was simply driving down the interstate with no connection to the chase. The impact was violent enough to set her vehicle on fire. Emergency crews responded quickly, but Born was pronounced dead at the scene.
Born was well known in Kanawha County as the owner of a strawberry farm and bed-and-breakfast, and she was a mother of six. Her death transformed what began as a vehicle-theft call into a genuine community loss, with neighbors sharing memories and disbelief across social media in the hours after the crash.
Charges And What Comes Next
Elswick survived the crash and was arrested at the scene. He faces charges of aggravated vehicular homicide and fleeing with reckless indifference, and investigators say additional charges are possible as the case develops. Toxicology results are still pending, and crash reconstruction teams are working through pursuit footage and witness accounts to establish the full sequence of events.
The Pursuit-Tactics Question This Reopens
Footage of the aftermath spreading online has reignited a debate that follows nearly every high-speed pursuit ending in tragedy: whether deploying spike strips on a busy interstate introduces its own danger, given how quickly a vehicle with shredded tires can become uncontrollable. Others argue the responsibility rests entirely with the decision to flee at 120 mph in a stolen vehicle in the first place, regardless of how the pursuit was managed.
Law enforcement agencies that use spike strips generally train for exactly this scenario, weighing the risk of a controlled tire deflation against the alternative of letting a stolen vehicle continue fleeing at high speed indefinitely. Neither option removes risk from a pursuit already unfolding on a live interstate — it only shifts where that risk lands, and in this case, it landed on a driver who had nothing to do with any of it.
None of the ongoing investigation changes the outcome for Born’s family. A stolen-vehicle call ended with the death of a mother and small business owner, and it leaves a hard question hanging over that stretch of I-64: when a fleeing suspect pushes a pursuit to 120 mph, who ultimately absorbs the consequences.
About the Author
