Carrie Underwood has confirmed she still owns the blue Ford Mustang she won more than two decades ago after taking first place on American Idol’s fourth season, and she’s not looking to part with it anytime soon.
Underwood’s 2005 Idol win came with the usual career-launching package: a recording contract and a Ford Mustang. Back then the car was essentially a bonus attached to a much bigger opportunity, a footnote to a life that was about to change dramatically. In a 2020 interview with Today’s Country Radio, she talked about what happened to that Mustang after the cameras stopped rolling, confirming she’d held onto it through the years rather than trading it in once her career took off.
Why the Mustang Still Matters
The car resurfaced publicly again in March 2025, when Underwood returned to American Idol to mentor a new crop of contestants chasing the same shot she once took. She was shown driving the Mustang on the show itself, a detail that did double duty: it confirmed she still has the car, and it tied her origin story directly to the same stage where she’s now offering guidance to the next generation of hopefuls.
It would have been easy for Underwood to let the Mustang go. Her career since 2005 has included stadium tours, platinum records, and a stack of major music awards, the kind of success that comes with access to essentially any car she wants. Instead, the Mustang stuck around as a constant through all of it, reportedly making the trip with her when she relocated to Tennessee to start her music career in earnest.
A Prize Car With Staying Power
There’s something fitting about a country star holding onto a Ford for twenty years instead of trading up. Reality-show prize cars usually get sold off quietly once the winner’s finances change, but Underwood’s Mustang has become part of her public narrative instead, a rolling reminder of the exact moment before anyone knew her name. As of her 2025 Idol appearance, there’s no indication she plans to sell or retire it. Two decades in, the car that came attached to her big break is still the one she’s driving.
About the Author
