Photo by Alfred GF on <a href="https://www.pexels.com/photo/nascar-cars-racing-on-a-track-11521138/" rel="nofollow">Pexels.com</a>
Garrett Mitchell, widely known to fans as Cleetus McFarland, is set to make his debut in the NASCAR O’Reilly Auto Parts Series at Rockingham Speedway on April 4, driving the No. 33 Chevrolet for Richard Childress Racing. The announcement that the popular YouTube personality will compete in multiple races under a two-year part-time deal immediately triggered debate across the NASCAR community. While the move brings one of the internet’s most recognizable automotive figures into a major national series, some established voices in the sport have questioned whether the opportunity aligns with the traditional pathway drivers typically follow to reach NASCAR’s upper tiers.
The reaction intensified after two-time NASCAR Cup Series champion Kyle Busch openly criticized the situation during race weekend at Phoenix. Busch pointed to the difference in experience between McFarland and drivers who typically spend years competing in lower-level series before reaching NASCAR’s national divisions. Busch also raised the point that his own young son has accumulated extensive racing experience, highlighting the long development process many drivers undergo before stepping into professional stock car competition. Busch’s comments quickly spread across the motorsports world, adding fuel to an already heated discussion about how drivers earn opportunities at the sport’s higher levels.
Now Busch’s stance has gained support from another prominent figure in NASCAR history. Former driver and long-time analyst Kyle Petty weighed in on the controversy during a discussion on NASCAR: Inside the Race. Petty addressed the situation directly, expressing skepticism about McFarland entering the O’Reilly Series despite having limited traditional racing experience compared with most drivers who reach that level.
Petty argued that the path to NASCAR’s national series has historically been built around competitive progression through developmental divisions. Drivers often begin in karting or grassroots racing, move into regional stock car series, and gradually advance through ARCA, the Truck Series, and the Xfinity level before reaching the top of the sport. Petty indicated that allowing someone to step into a national series seat without extensive time climbing that ladder raises questions about how those opportunities are awarded.
At the same time, Petty acknowledged that motorsports has long included promotional elements that help attract fans and sponsors. Well-known personalities entering races can generate attention and bring new audiences to the sport. However, Petty emphasized that NASCAR competition is highly professional and typically demands years of experience behind the wheel before drivers can perform consistently at the national level.
The debate surrounding McFarland’s entry into the O’Reilly Series highlights a growing tension within modern motorsports. On one side, racing organizations increasingly recognize the marketing value of drivers with large online followings. On the other side, veteran drivers and industry figures often emphasize the importance of experience, racecraft, and time spent developing skills through traditional racing channels.
Mitchell built his massive following through automotive content centered around high-performance builds, motorsports events, and racing-themed entertainment. His Cleetus McFarland brand has attracted millions of subscribers and created a loyal fan base that closely follows his projects and racing activities. That popularity played a major role in bringing attention to his move into NASCAR competition.
Despite the criticism from some corners of the sport, McFarland has gained at least some racing experience in recent seasons. In 2025, he ran a part-time schedule in the ARCA Menards Series, a common development platform for drivers looking to move toward NASCAR’s national divisions. ARCA events often serve as a proving ground where young drivers gain experience on larger tracks while adjusting to stock car competition.
McFarland also made his NASCAR Truck Series debut earlier this year at Daytona, marking his first start in one of NASCAR’s three national touring series. The Daytona event provided an early look at how the YouTube personality would handle racing against professional drivers on one of the sport’s most challenging superspeedways.
Still, critics argue that those appearances represent only a small amount of experience compared with the years many drivers spend working their way through the ranks. NASCAR’s development ladder is known for being difficult to climb, with thousands of drivers competing in regional and developmental series for only a handful of seats at the national level.
The limited number of opportunities in NASCAR’s top divisions makes each available ride highly competitive. Young drivers often spend years building resumes, winning races in feeder series, and securing sponsorship backing in hopes of eventually earning a chance with a major team. For many of those competitors, breaking into NASCAR’s upper levels remains a long and uncertain process.
That context is part of what fuels criticism from drivers and analysts who question fast-track opportunities tied to popularity rather than racing results. Some in the industry believe that national series seats should primarily go to drivers with the most proven competitive track records.
Even with that criticism, NASCAR teams ultimately make decisions based on a combination of factors that include performance potential, sponsor backing, and marketing value. Drivers who bring significant audience attention can sometimes help teams secure partnerships that support racing programs financially.
Richard Childress Racing’s decision to place McFarland in the No. 33 Chevrolet reflects that broader business reality within modern motorsports. High-profile personalities entering races can create major online engagement, draw new viewers, and generate additional attention for teams and sponsors.
The upcoming Rockingham race will mark McFarland’s first start in the O’Reilly Auto Parts Series, placing him directly into one of NASCAR’s most competitive environments. Rockingham Speedway itself carries historical significance within the sport, known for producing challenging races that test driver skill and car control.
Whether McFarland proves competitive or struggles against more experienced drivers remains to be seen. What is certain is that his debut has already sparked one of the most talked-about discussions in NASCAR this season.
For now, the focus shifts to April 4, when McFarland will officially take the green flag at Rockingham behind the wheel of Richard Childress Racing’s No. 33 Chevrolet. His performance on track will ultimately determine how the conversation surrounding his NASCAR opportunity evolves from here.
Source
About the Author
