In 1973, the serene town of Gila Bend, Arizona, became the backdrop for a Hollywood mystery involving star Burt Reynolds and British actress Sarah Miles. It all began with Reynolds’ birthday party at the Pink Palomino in nearby Ajo, an event that business manager David Whiting was not invited to.
The Night Turns Dark
Post-celebration, some cast members, including Reynolds and Miles, continued drinking at the Travelodge motel in Gila Bend. Miles, after spending time in Reynolds’ room, returned to her own to find an irate Whiting questioning her. His jealousy led to a physical confrontation, prompting Miles to scream for help, which brought Reynolds to the scene and caused Whiting to flee.
A Gruesome Discovery
The following morning, the situation took a grim turn when Miles found Whiting’s dead body in her room. The scene was distressing, with Whiting lying in a pool of blood, sparking a series of investigations.
Inconsistencies and Alterations in Testimonies
Initially, Miles reported a non-violent encounter with Whiting, but later changed her statement to describe a violent altercation. Reynolds, involved as a key witness, had removed a vial from Whiting’s hand, the contents and whereabouts of which he couldn’t later recall.
The Inquest and MGM’s Resistance
Despite Metro-Goldwyn-Mayer’s objections over production costs, an inquest was held where Reynolds and Miles recounted their versions of the events. The official ruling declared Whiting’s death as an overdose, but questions lingered due to the unexplained blood at the scene.
Sarah Miles: The Central Figure
Sarah Miles, known for her roles in significant films and rumored to have affairs with both Reynolds and Whiting, found herself at the heart of this mystery. Her changing testimonies and the alleged romantic entanglements added layers of complexity to the case.
Unanswered Questions
The case of David Whiting’s death remained shrouded in mystery, with theories ranging from a simple overdose to a violent altercation. The involvement of Reynolds and Miles only heightened the intrigue, leaving a story filled with speculation and unanswered questions in Hollywood history.
33 thoughts on “The Gila Bend Mystery: Burt Reynolds, Sarah Miles, And The Untold Story”